Option 2:
1) What are your "student bird" and "teacher bird" thoughts about assigning percentages or letter grades in the assessment of student work? What do the grades indicate? How are they arrived at? Whose purposes do they serve? What are positive and negative aspects to giving grades? to be assigned grades by an instructor?
As a current student in the Bachelor of Education program, and as someone who just finished my Bachelor of Mathematics in April, I'm finding the jump from grading and marks being so important to a pass/fail system very relieving. I am someone who puts a lot of pressure on myself to receive good marks, but I found with percent grades I would always get frustrated and wonder why I got for example 79% instead of 80%. I'm finding that I'm able to express myself more in this program now with pass/fail since I'm not as worried about my specific grades. I'm worrying less about having the exact answer that my profs are looking for and now am doing things the way that I enjoy the best or the way that I learn the best so I'm really enjoying the switch.
As a teacher, I find assigning percentages very difficult. Similarly to from my student perspective, I would struggle to explain to a student why they got 79% and not 80%. I find that giving letter grades easier for me to justify, since I can make criteria that a student much reach for me to justify giving them the specific letter grade.
2) What are some of the unintended side effects of grading? How do grades and marks in themselves format the social relations and learning situations in a classroom, a school, a district?
I think that an unintended side effect of grading is how we perceive students and how they perceive each other. We may have an expectation of certain students to either do good or do bad depending on what we have seen from them on previous tests and projects or from what other teachers tell us about our experiences with them. This also causes students who usually do well a higher amount of pressure to receive a certain percentage which can lead to more stress in their lives.
3) Could you imagine teaching math and/or science without giving grades? How could a teacher encourage learning without having an emphasis on grading?
I think that teaching math without giving any grades would be difficult. I especially think this is difficult for students in grades 11 and 12 who are looking to pursue academics because of the expectations of universities. Students in those cases will always be looking for a better percent grade so they're more likely to get into the school of their choice. However, I think it is possible in other cases. I think that having the proficiency scale is very good to encourage learning without the grade emphasis because it helps students see in what areas they can work on the most and what they are excelling on.